unsolved murders in logan county ohio unsolved murders in logan county ohio

One of the more recognizable murders in Logan that most people of today can identify with is that of young Mamie Thurman; her devilish murder occurring in 1932 and leaving many unanswered questions still today. Ahntastic Adventures in Silicon Valley 2023 Advance Local Media LLC. Incident location: Cincinnati, Ohio. But Traficant was acquitted after he told a jury he had been conducting a secret sting operation. A squirrel hunter in woods 3 miles from the Heberts' home and a mile south of Mitchell DeWitt Road (near where Franklin, Delaware and Union counties meet) stumbled across a partially decomposed body that fall. The 42-year-old sheriff has refused to resign after being indicted. Democrat Wayne Hays served in U.S. House of Representatives from 1949 to 1976 and was known for his firm rule of the Committee on House Administration. His alibi for the night of the Schneider murders was never fully corroborated. Theresa Smith Unsolved homicide. The victims, Melvin Baisden, 74, Ervin Johnson Schoolcraft, 51, and 22-year-old Vicie Lucinda (Lilly) White, a widow from Varney in Mingo County, were found the morning of June 15 in a one-room cabin near the Pecks Mill location. Hoffman hid their bodies inside a tree in the Kokosing Lake Wildlife Area, according to The Columbus Dispatch. Historians Don't Actually Believe Frank Sheeran Killed Jimmy Hoffa. According to police, White had been living with Schoolcraft, who was found lying across the bed with one bullet hole in the left temple. Please SIGN THE PETITIONon this websitecalling for official reinvestigation and DNA testing of all applicable existing evidence in the Mansfield, Martin, and Schneider murder cases. Taylors husband found her beaten and apparently raped at their home on Oct. 29, 1966. The family dropped the lawsuit after Ohio announced it would stop using the two drugs used in the execution. Mansfield failed to appear in court for the March hearing, and the matter was continued and a warrant was issued for his arrest. Moran spent most of the rest of his life in prison before dying in custody in 1957. Warren Township resident Noal Quattlebaum strangled his girlfriend to death in 2008. Investigators say Overmyer was improperly taking drugs from the drop boxes. He fled before Richard could get his gun loaded. She even went as far as to travel to Marietta where she was able to find the house where she believed she lived during the past life as well as the gravesite of Sandra's grandmother. 1976 Logan County murders and probable cover-up Lincoln, IL realtor Ruth Louise Martin, 51, has been missing from her home since the morning of Wednesday, June 2, 1976. He is currently serving nearly 11 years for his role in a million-dollar sports ticket fraud. Magnolia resident Thomas Lee Dillon shot and killed five men during a three-year period from 1989 to 1992. On October 18, Smrekar and three of his friends were at the Logan County Courthouse for a hearing on the Kroger case, and Russell was arrested for the Fry double homicide. My father, Logan County States Attorney Roger W. Thompson (1972-1980), alerted authorities the morning of Oct. 10th that Jay Fry and Ruth Martin were witnesses in the Kroger shoplifting case. Former Lucas County Republican Party chairman Tom Noe is serving 18 years in prison for taking $13.7 million from $50 million the state's Bureau of Worker's Compensation invested in rare-coin funds. Cold Cases Missing Persons Daily Archive. William A. Krueger and Thomas Maurer were the leading Lincoln PD detectives assigned to the Martin case in 76, and both men lied to me about the facts pertaining to the T-shirt. I now regret having delayed meeting with him it was an opportunity lost. He reportedly made adeathbed confession to killing Mansfield and Martin before expiring from a terminal illness at Menard Penitentiary. Chester McKnight shot and killed Todd Schultz and Annette Cooper in 1982 in Logan. The U.S. Supreme Court in 2010 refused to hear his appeal. Hensley later strangled a fellow prison inmate in 2002, according to the Associated Press. Anyone With A Heart Will Love The New Ohio Law That Just Went Into Effect, The 15 Downright Scariest Things To Ever Come Out Of Ohio, History Has Forgotten This Bizarre Ohio Event From 90 Years Ago. Lane is now incarcerated at the maximum-security Southern Ohio Correctional Facility. Baumeister escaped to Ontario, Canada and committed suicide before police could take him into custody, according to The New York Times. However, to name but a very few, we should list the 1917 shooting death of young Frank Kazee by Don Chafin, former 1912 sheriff of Logan, who would again be elected in 1920 after sitting out the required four years prior and serving as county clerk at the time that he shot backseat passenger Kazee over what today would be described as road rage. Chafin, of course, was declared not guilty by a jury. Chrishana Logan was 19 years old when. The greatest hindrance in 76 was that forensic capabilities were not what they are today, but there are other bothersome things that I cant explain. Maurer, whos now unfortunately deceased, claimed in March of 2002 that he didnt know anything about a T-shirt. Forensic evidence from the scene, which still exists, excluded Larry Taylor as his wifes killer. Dillon was arrested on weapons charges in 1992 and later pleaded guilty to the murders to avoid the death penalty. According to the reports filed that day, and later, the county sheriff's office received a report at 10:30 a.m. Aug. 30, 2005, that the patrol responded to a traffic crash . John Spirko Jr. has been sentenced to life in prison for the 1982 murder of Elgin postmaster Betty Jane Mottinger. He later became an investment banker and author. Morans rival Al Capone likely ordered the killings. Blood and a mutilated spent .22 caliber bullet were found in the Martin garage. Former superintendent Mike McVey had also been accused of misleading authorities investigating the case. Former U.S. Rep. Jim Traficant saw his career end in disgrace in 2002. Charles Manson, Jeffrey Dahmer and Ariel Castro are just a few of the criminals who've called Ohio home. Produce employee Jay Alvin Fry had seen Smrekar lift the steaks and stick them under his jacket. Fischer killed Abi Matthews at her Malta home in 2009. Months later, on Oct. 9, 76, Jay Fry and his 3-months-pregnant wife, Robin, both 24, were shot-gunned to death in their home just 9 days prior to a scheduled hearing on the Kroger case. Hensley hanged himself in his cell in 2015. But the discovery of his plot led to his execution. The harasser has never been seen and the police have no leads on who he or she may be, though it's possible a neighbor, "friend," or family member is the cause, given the degree of knowledge of the Wacker's that he or she had. The police investigated several leads, including one that involved an unidentified man spray painting "I Love You Cindy" on a wall near her office, but she was never found. If you enjoyed this slideshow, check out more of our prior slideshows below. For example, in 2002, former Logan County States Attorney Tim Huyett requested the handwritten Schneider crime lab report from the state crime lab archives; found on the clothes and under the Schneider victims fingernails were foreign fibers and two different colored foreign hairs that did not belong to them or Drabing. Michelle Bica kidnapped the pregnant Theresa Andrews, shot her and cut her baby from her womb on Sept. 27, 2000 in Ravenna. But then it disappeared, as had Herbert. McGuires family filed a federal lawsuit after he gasped and choked throughout the 24-minute process. A Monroe County jury convicted Ash at trial and a judge handed down his sentence in January 2016. Detectives said Roush had more than 1,000 marijuana plants growing behind his rural home. Ted Strickland cited a lack of physical evidence in the case when he commuted Spirko's death sentence in 2008, according to The Toledo Blade. Nancy Schneider, the eldest of the three Schneider daughters,had a huge outdoor party at the Schneider farm one monthprior to the stabbings. He apparently didnt say what he did with Mansfield. The victims were Lisa Watters and Andy Hussey. Sara Carruthers one of 22 Ohio House members censured for backing Iron Rose Mercantile opens expanded location in Middletown, New Ohio cold case unit looking into unsolved homicide of Fairfield 15-year-old. Belt pleaded guilty to tax evasion and prostitution charges and spent four years in a federal prison in Arizona, according to The Toledo Gazette. On Dec. 21, 1983, her husband, Richard Zastudil, left for work about 7:15 a.m. and her kids got on the school bus an hour later. Quattlebaum committed suicide in prison in 2013, according to The Marietta Times. Two weeks later, on April 8, a state game warden looking to check the licenses of fishermen happened across Thompsons body on an embankment off the 260 block of East Kemper Road. Neither Krueger nor the Lincoln PD will account for its whereabouts they are remaining silent. Roush was wearing a bulletproof vest and armed with an assault rifle when he opened fire on deputies, according to WBNS-10TV. Theres no doubt he was involved in the murders of Mansfield and Martin, but the facts and evidence in those cases support that he used accomplices. His lies have demonstrated a clear intent to obstruct justice and cover-up critical information connected to vital blood evidence in an unsolved murder. Mansfield signed the Deferral of Prosecution Agreement on Dec. 18th and then went home to spend the Christmas/New Years holidays with his family. Get Alerts Map; Browse By State; Submit a Crime Tip Square with arrow pointing upper right. But the Ohio Attorney Generals Office dropped the charges in exchange for his resignation. He never told his mother who called, he just said he was going out for an hour or so and would be back. Castro pleaded guilty and was subsequently sentenced to life plus 1,000 years in prison. Bonnie J. Thompson, Investigative Writer/Author(Copyright 2013, 2015, 2017). The Murder of Joseph Kupchik. He reportedly made adeathbed confession to killing Mansfield and Martin before expiring from a terminal illness at Menard Penitentiary. Fox received a death sentence and died by lethal injection in 2003. Interestingly, the T-shirt is the only item of evidence in the Martin case thats allegedly MISSING from the Lincoln PD, without explanation. To request that an unsolved homicide be included in BCI's statewide database and featured on this website, Ohio law enforcement agencies should contact BCI at 855-BCI-OHIO (224-6446) or e-mail OhioUnsolvedHomicides@OhioAttorneyGeneral.gov and reference Ohio Unsolved Homicides. Crime Map. But there was a problem. Davis was arrested in May in Hamilton County on a felony charge of promoting prostitution and is awaiting trial. Detectives arrested Reese a diagnosed schizophrenic released to his sisters care in 1954 while investigating the disappearance of a car salesman found buried at the farm. Investigators found 11 bodies buried at Herb Baumeisters farm outside Indianapolis in 1996. Fible said she believes the case was botched from the beginning because detectives placed blame on her. Officers said Mrs. Serey had been despondent since the birth of her last child. He also claimed he rested for a bit. James Goff has been sentenced to death for the Sept. 15, 1994 murder of 88-year-old Myrtle Rutledge at her house in Wilmington. She was last seen at 1:15 a.m. near Fifth and Madison in Covington, Kentucky, attempting to obtain a ride to her home in Latonia, Kentucky. In 2007, he accepted a plea bargain that led to his release from prison and return to his native Scotland. Crime in Logan County, Ohio. Like the feud, it is a Logan County historical masterpiece. Fortune-teller Andrew F. Tyler committed the county's first murder and was executed in the county's only recorded hanging in 1849, according to The Bryan Times. 0:45 BELLEFONTAINE, Ohio -- Carl Stevenson apparently was blabbing to authorities about the unsolved disappearance and likely murder of 18-year-old Mike Lattimer in Logan County. The following are what we consider to be some of the creepiest, strangest and most unsettling unsolved mysteries that have taken place in the state. She disappeared 6 days before she was to testify against defendant Russell Albin Smrekar, 21, in a Lincoln grocery store shoplifting case. He put on his buckskin coat and walked out the front door, leaving his wallet behind. You will receive your first email soon. He apparently didnt say what he did with Mansfield. After working a 48-hour shift at the hospital, the nurse anesthetist told her mother around 4 p.m. that she was going out for a jog. She was subpoenaed for the second trial, but it was declared a mistrial before she testified. Marie Poling is serving 20 years to life in prison for the 1987 murder of her husband in Howland. Logan County authorities are ignoring the new information, facts, and evidence Ive brought forth in the Martin and Schneider cases. Theres no doubt he was involved in the murders of Mansfield and Martin, but the facts and evidence in those cases support that he used accomplices. Lincoln resident Michael Edward Drabing, 21, was arrested and convicted for single-handedly murdering the Schneiders. She was alive, and her husband ran for help from friends who had just dropped him off from work. Investigators are still searching for the person or persons who killed eight members of the Rhoden family on April 22, 2016. Scaggs the year before had killed a man during a poker game at Chapmanville. Randle Lee Roberts II shot and killed four family members, including an 11-year-old girl, in 2011 in West Union. This is the name that will be displayed next to your photo for comments, blog posts, and more. Reese spent 11 years in a state asylum before he died in 1966, according to the New York Daily News. Milan, Ohio is best known for being the birthplace of Thomas Edison. I was 19 and a deputy circuit clerk at the Logan County courthouse in76 when Ruth Martin disappeared and the Schneiders were so horrifically slain. He then raped the girl before beheading both of the children, according to the website Forgotten Ohio. But she shot herself Oct. 2, 2000 as investigators arrived at her home, The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette said. Marysville native Nathan Gale killed Damageplan guitarist Dimebag Darrell Lance Albert who earlier founded Pantera and three others at a Dec. 8, 2004 concert in Columbus. EAST LIVERPOOL, Ohio (WKBN) For over 46 years, Rhoda Monigold has had a hole in her heart. And that was the beginning of what would become antenna television in southern West Virginia. The history of Logan County is vast, and its longtime existence is marked by numerous tales of murder, beginning as far back as the 1700s when Aracoma and her tribe were attacked at what is now Midelburg Island in Logan. Ten-year-old Amy Mihaljevic was abducted from the Bay Village Shopping Center on Oct. 27, 1989. No one has seen him since that cold December day. Harrison had been raped and strangled before investigators found her body six days later. It was suspected by many that an accomplice had driven Drabing home, and the number one named suspect was Pat Hanley. BURIED TRUTH The Unabridged Trilogy Copyright 2013, 2015, 2017 By Bonnie J. Thompson. Brabander had been fishing with his parents near Kelleys Island when Mastronardi rammed their boat with his speedboat. States Attorney Thompson and his assistant, John Foltz, offered to defer Mansfields charges if he would agree to turn states evidence and testify against Smrekar in the burglary case. All Rights Reserved. He was released from prison in 2017, according to the Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Correction. Search Ohio homicide victims by name, city or keywords. When she's not on deadline or chasing after her toddler, she's hunting for hidden gems in Ohio or getting lost in a good book. She would be the only survivor. The facts and evidence support that Drabing did not act alone. Then he and another man cut up their bodies and buried parts along the Hocking River. Johnson threatened the woman with a knife and forced her to give him $1,000, claiming her son had been kidnapped. Rick Jones was Judge Thorntons 21-year-old bailiffinthe courthouse the spring and summer of 76. Actually, though, it was not until The Logan Banner, then called the The Logan County Banner, came into existence in 1888 that news, including many murders, were documented in the form of newsprint. Sheriff's deputies called in the guardsmen to protect Mitchell from a mob outside the jail, according to The New York Times. One of the letter recipient's husband was murdered, which was believed to be connected to the letters, and the letters continued even after a suspect was placed in prison. He convinced an accomplice to lure a child into the woods and feed her arsenic laced-candy. The new unit based at the. Love Ohio? Ohio city ranked second safest small city or town in U.S. 'The final straw;' Mikesell's . Angela Kilgore Age. John Warren Parsons shot and killed Chillicothe police officer Larry R. Cox while fleeing a gas station robbery in 2005. Fairfield Detective Doug Day said the department investigates all leads. George D. Davis II, of Cincinnati, was sent to prison for drug trafficking, importuning, and having weapons under disability for attempting to exchange heroin for sex with Johnson, but was never charged in connection with her slaying. Thank you! Cold cases and unsolved crimes in Logan County, OH. The Kirtland cult leader claimed God commanded him to kill the five members of the Avery family on April 17, 1989. But it was his execution that attracted international attention. Buell had also been suspected of killing a 12-year-old girl in 1981 and a 10-year-old girl in 1983. He disappeared, The same day Mansfield disappeared, the burglary matter was continued to March (unbeknownst to Mansfield and Smrekar) because the two female students whose dorm room had been burgled were still on their European vacation. Sorry, there are no recent results for popular commented articles. He didnt have a vehicle, so he was on foot. THE MISSING BLOODY T-SHIRT IS THE SMOKING GUN. He was sentenced to life in prison for those crimes. Whether this is a true example of reincarnation or not is unknown. In 2009, a Lorain County judge sentenced him to at least 23 years in prison. There were/are manyanomalies in the Schneider case, too many to bring out in this writing, but Ill mention a few. Your purchase was successful, and you are now logged in. He committed suicide a month into his prison term. Her body was found in a ditch days later, and investigators arrested Fox the next month. And,. The 1986 murder of Theresa Ann Woods, the 1963 murder of Irene Wilson, the 1982 murder of LaRoy Earl Gorman, and the 2008 murder of Judith Lynn Petty are among the unsolved central West Virginia murders, in addition to the 1945 kidnapping and mysterious disappearance of the Sodder Children. Dahmer killed 16 others in Wisconsin before being arrested in 1991. Some of the counties were more difficult than others. She was seen at the market talking on the payphone, and her bicycle was still out front when the store closed at 8 p.m. Baisden, a former Peach Creek railroader, was found just inside the cabin with a bullet hole squarely between his eyes, the bullet exiting the back of his head. Sheriff Henry declared the mystery solved: "It was horribly tragic, a murder/suicide case."Three days later, Stacy woke up in intensive care. Christopher Newton died by lethal injection for the 2003 murder of his cellmate at the Mansfield Correctional Institution. Russell had two girlfriends at the time of the disappearances of Mansfield and Martin, and they undoubtedly know more than theyve ever admitted. While we don't know the exact number of how many Marion County murders have occurred in recent years, the Federal Bureau of Investigation's annual Uniform Crime Reports can at least provide some reliable information. Since Ruths remains have never been found, I have serious questions about the LPDs, Everybody likes a good whodonnit, [sic] and reality is that they [the Mansfield and Martin cases] are and will remain unto eternity, Im asking the public and the media those of you reading this to take an interest in these unsolved/unresolved murders Ive been reinvestigating for nearly 20 years. He died in 2015 after spending nearly two decades in a behavioral health facility in Athens, according to The Daily Independent. If you forget it, you'll be able to recover it using your email address. According to these past reports, there were 2 Marion County murders in 2015, 5 in 2016, 7 in 2017, 3 in 2018, and 6 in 2019. That night, Smrekar showed up at Mansfields dorm room with an armload of LPs wanting to store them there temporarily. Login; Logan County, OH Area Cold Cases. Although several friends and relatives of the victims were questioned concerning the shooting, no definite clues were ever discovered, and the deaths were never solved. Hall, who suffered a brain injury as a child, was ruled incompetent to stand trial. Joy Hoop is also serving 25 years in prison for her role in the murder. On September 18, 75, Smrekar stole 150 record albums and an expensive B.C. Lead agency: Cincinnati Police Department. On Wednesday, August 18, 76, the day before the Schneiders demise, Jones approached me in the back of the circuit clerks office and told me with a smirk on his face, Somethin big and somethin bads gonna happen. The only big and bad thing that happened in Lincoln immediately following his ominous prediction was the Schneider triple homicide. Missing persons, signs of extra terrestrial life and thousands of anonymous, vindictive letters are just a few of the uncanny happenings in Ohio that have yet to be solved over the years in spite of ongoing investigations. Shane Roush has been sentenced to 25 years in prison for his role in a shootout that seriously injured a Morrow County Sheriff's deputy in 2010. Additionally, a man later came forward claiming that he was the reincarnation of Sandra's boyfriend and that he had several of the same memories that Georgia had. Herbert Meeker, who went to the electric chair in 1933, is the last person executed from the Tuscarawas Valley, according to The Times-Reporter. Do they share the same killer? Prior to 2002, not many people knew much, or anything, about it. In light of Kruegers egregious lies and the importance of the details relating to the T-shirt, that evidence most assuredly did not disappear (if its really missing) by accident, and it also didnt sprout legs and walk out of the LPD on its own. 8 unsolved murders in the Miami Valley. Dillinger robbed two-dozen banks and four police stations and twice escaped jail before being killed in a shootout outside a Chicago theater in 1934. James Worley is charged with murder in the death of college student Sierah Joughin, who was found in a shallow grave on July 22, 2016. Prohibition-era gangster Adelard Cunin better known as Bugs Moran rose to prominence in Chicago. It turned out to be Herbert, half-dressed, likely sexually assaulted and beaten to death. Someone had attempted to wipe up the blood on the Martins garage floor the day Ruth vanished, and it had been spread out over a larger area. Georgia claimed that she had strange visions since she was a child about a woman and the 1900s. Goff had delivered furniture to the house earlier that day and went back to commit a robbery, according to court records. Matthew Hoffman avoided the death penalty by pleading guilty to the 2010 murders of two women and an 11-year-old boy. Login; Meigs County, OH Area Cold Cases.